Finance and Economic Opportunities
For the period during which Mr Alan Winde was the Minister of this Department (2009–2014 and 2014–2018):
(a) How many official trips or delegations related to the Western Cape Provincial Parliament or to departmental business did he gone on, (b) what was the purpose of the delegation’s travel, (c) which committee or department organised the trip for the delegation, (d) where did the delegation go (to which country and/or province), (e)(i) what was the duration of the trip, (ii) which locations were visited and (iii) how many days or nights were spent at each location, (f)(i) which officials were met during the delegation’s visit, (ii) which meetings were scheduled and (iii) which meetings were actually attended, (g) what are the names of the other MPPs and/or Ministers and Western Cape Government officials who were part of the delegation and (h) what were the outcomes of each of these delegations in benefit to the province as applicable?
As the Provincial Minister responsible for Economic Opportunities, Alan Winde played a leading role in promoting tourism, trade and investment to the Western Cape as part of his focus on facilitating economic growth and job creation. This remains our top priority today.
This promotion was done in terms of the shared Constitutional competency that provinces have in this regard, so that economic growth could be facilitated to the benefit of the Western Cape and South Africa.
This Economic Diplomacy for the province was also important to promote the Western Cape as a business-friendly destination given the national context of declining business confidence.
I have been advised, as set out in the tables below, of the following international trips undertaken by Alan Winde as Minister of Economic Opportunities between 2009 and 2018.[1]
|
VISIT TO PARIS AND BOURGOGNE-FRANCE-COMTE, 29 June until 08 July 2018 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier [Bourgogne-France-Comte leg] and Wesgro [Paris leg] |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The primary aim of the visit was to promote the Western Cape as preferred Trade, Tourism and Investment destination in France through meeting with several entities such as Business France, MEDEF, BPI France. One of the key outcomes was a stronger working relationship with La French Tech, which launched a successful incubator in Cape Town. The visit also resulted in the signing of a new twinning arrangement with Bourgogne-Franche-Comte [B-F-C]. The cooperation with B-F-C is one of the province’s long standing twinning arrangements. Key successes under the twinning arrangement is the training provided to farm and cellar workers [viticulture training] and workers in the cheese industry. |
|
ATTENDANCE OF 9TH REGIONAL LEADERS’ SUMMIT, 16 until 18 May 2018 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
Quebec City, Canada, 16 until 18 May 2018 [3 working days] |
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The purpose of the visit was to attend the 9th Regional Leaders’ Summit. The bulk of the Western Cape’s international engagements took place within the ambit of the Regional Leaders’ Forum. The 9th forum took place under the theme “Energy Transition: Towards a Low-carbon Economy”. The visit also presented the Western Cape with an opportunity to strengthen its bilateral relations with its partner regions, bearing in mind that the bulk of the Western Cape’s international engagements happens within the ambit of the Regional Leaders forum. The visit also resulted in the signing of an agreement between GreenCape and Ecotech Quebec to promote business to business relations in the Green Economy. |
|
VISIT TO THE UNITED KINGDOM AND THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES, 04 until 10 November 2017 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of Economic Development and Tourism and Wesgro |
Delegation in addition to Minister Winde
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The delegation attended the WTM, on the invitation of the Nelson Mandela Foundation and the Thebe group. Meetings were attended and participated [Minister Winde was a panellist during a session on Responsible Tourism] in to promote the Western Cape as a premier tourism destination. A 9-bedroom boutique hotel [Mandela Presidential centre] was also launched during the event. In addition, various engagement took place on the margin of the WTM with global stakeholders regarding the promotion of the WC as a global Halaal source market, including for Asia and the UK. Discussions were also entered into regarding the formalisation of a trade agreement between the DIT UK and the Western Cape, bearing in mind the strategic importance of the UK as a market for the province. Furthermore, lessons learned were also shared and implemented as far as the UK’s handling of past droughts were concerned, particularly the usage of technology therein. Lastly, discussions were entered into with Pinewood Film studios regarding the reignition of the Themba Sibeko project with the Cape Point Film Studio. In the UAE, the delegation experienced first-hand the possibilities offered by desalination plants and the usage of solar energy therein. Discussions were also entered into with the Masdar City Special Economic Zone regarding its offering and its marketing strategy. Lastly discussions were entered into with relevant experts regarding potential linkages for Halaal exports into the UAE. |
|
VISIT TO: UNITED KINGDOM, 20 until 28 May 2017 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Wesgro |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
Due to Brexit, the aim of the visit was to maintain the province’s market share in the UK from a Trade, Tourism and Investment perspective, and look for growth opportunities in high growth sectors. The UK has traditionally been an important market for the province and the intention was to speak to key political interlocutors wielding influence in the UK government as far as UK-SA investment opportunities are concerned. In addition, discussions were also entered into with potential investors in the Renewable Energy and Oil and gas sectors [promoting the offering of the Saldanha Bay IDZ] as well as key players in the tourism industry. Discussions were also entered into with Virgin Airlines regarding a direct flight into Cape Town. Similar discussions also took place with key interlocutors in Scotland, including with the Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce. |
|
VISIT TO THE UNITED STATES, 10 until 20 October 2016 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Wesgro |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
Even though the main purpose of the visit was to attend the IMEX America, a global exhibition for the MICE industry [incentive travel, meetings and events], the visit also presented opportunities to promote the Western Cape as preferred Trade, Tourism and Investment destination. In particular, the visit promoted the Western Cape as a preferred film destination by engaging with stakeholders regarding the offering of the province and obtain an understanding of the impediments / challenges experienced by the industry preventing them from utilising the province as a destination. Discussions were also entered into and valuable insighted gained with stakeholders regarding positioning the Western Cape as a Technology and Innovation Hub for Africa. These insights influenced the strategic thinking of the province in positioning the province as a technology and innovation hub. Stakeholders were also engaged regarding design initiatives. |
|
VISIT TO THE PEOPLES’ REPUBLIC OF CHINA, 07 until 15 November 2015 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier and Wesgro |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The primary aim of the visit was to promote the Western Cape as preferred Trade, Tourism and Investment destination in China by meeting with industry bodies and companies in Hong Kong, Shanghai and Beijing, which was covered extensively by media in China. The delegation participated in the Food and Hotel China and PROWINE China, the premium show for the hospitality industry in China and which was frequented by several wineries from the province. A meeting also took place with Perfect China, the biggest importer of wine into China from the Western Cape to obtain a sense of what could be done to increase exports into China. The visit presented an opportunity to hear first-hand challenges experienced by tour operators, companies and industry bodies wanting to invest in South Africa and vice versa, in sectors such as Tourism, Agriculture, Film sector, Construction and Manufacturing to mention but a few. The visit also presented opportunities to promote the offering of the SBIDZ as well as the ASEZ, as far as Oil and Gas and Renewable Energy were concerned, including Longyuan Power Group and Jinko Solar which are currently based in Cape Town. Lastly discussions were entered into with Air China regarding increased air access into the province. |
|
VISIT TO ANGOLA, 26 until 28 April 2015 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
Luanda, 26 until 28 September 2011 [3 working days][10] |
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The visit presented an opportunity to engage with the stakeholders in Angola to explore closer cooperation with the Western Cape. The visit was a result of an invitation received from the governor of Luanda following previous visits by Wesgro, the Western Cape Government, DTI, Trade and Investment KwaZulu-Natal to Angola. The objective of the visit was to explore closer ties between the Western Cape and the Luanda Province, Angola. The visit also allowed the WCG to engage with strategic counterparts and created a platform for businesses to advance their interests in the Angolan market. A clear sense was also obtained of the opportunities in the Angolan market as well as possible impediments to increased business relations including in the Tourism and Hospitality, Agriculture, Energy and Construction sectors. A follow-up visit by the Minister of Tourism was subsequently facilitated by the Western Cape. |
|
VISIT TO THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES [UAE] AND MALAYSIA, 27 March until 03 April 2015 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Wesgro |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The primary purpose of the visit was to attend the AIM congress, the premier investment conference in the UAE. In addition, the delegation explored closer collaboration regarding the export of horses into the UAE, including identifying blockages and ways of circumventing it. Similar discussions also took place regarding the direct exportation of diamonds from the Western Cape [currently done via Gauteng]. A clearer sense was also obtained regarding opportunities [Agricultural products] and hinderances to closer trade relations, including existing visa regime, etc. This also applied to tourism opportunities, including the development of joint marketing strategies and programmes with relevant stakeholders, learn best practices from Dubai regarding their tourism promotion strategy, etc. In addition, Minister Winde witnesses the signing of a Declaration of Intent between the Western Cape Fine Foods Initiative [WCFFI] and the Halal Industrial Development Cooperation [HDC] regarding investment in an Halaal Industrial Park in Cape Town. Discussions were also entered into with the Malaysia Industry-Government Group for High-Technology regarding the establishment of a Halaal Industrial Hub in the Western Cape. |
|
VISIT TO THE NETHERLANDS, 03 until 08 June 2013 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of Economic Development and Tourism |
Delegation
|
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
Netherlands, 04 until 08 June 2013 [4 working days] |
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The visit provided the WCG with a better understanding of the business-to-business relations between the Netherlands and South Africa and how the Western Cape can strategically position itself to benefit optimally from this relationship from a Trade, Tourism and Investment promotion perspective. Significant media coverage was also enjoyed during the visit, assisting in the promotion of the province. The meetings also enable the Western Cape to identify blockages preventing closer business relations and undertake efforts to eliminate those, bearing in mind the strategic importance of the Netherlands for the WC as a market. Exchange of best practice and know-how took place with the Dutch Cycling Embassy [Cycling and Cycling tourism], Brainport Eindhoven [Innovation and Technology, in particular how the Western Cape could position itself as an Innovation and Tech hub on the African continent], Eindhoven Design Academy [Creative industries]. |
|
VISIT TO THE UNITED KINGDOM AND GERMANY, 30 September until 06 October 2012 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The aim of the visit was to promote the Western Cape as a preferred Trade, Tourism and Investment destination, bearing in mind the events that unfolded at Marikana and the potential impact it could have on the image of South Africa as a destination. As such, the visit presented an opportunity to allay the fears of investors regarding the attractiveness of the province as a destination through meetings with investors [in various guises and forms] as well as interviews conducted. The visit also presented an opportunity to exchange best practices with entities such as International Synergies Ltd, e.g. the lessons learned regarding the industrial symbiosis process implemented by International Synergies informed the functions of the delivery unit implemented in the office of the Premier. Exchange of best practice was also entered into with VisitBritain regarding campaigns they ran to optimise the attractiveness of the country as a destination follow the Olympics. The visit to Bavaria presented an opportunity to further strengthen the bilateral relations with the Free State of Bavaria, a partner region of the province, particularly from an economic development perspective. Discussions were entered into with tour operators in Bavaria regarding their offering to tourists in the Western Cape and impediments to increasing the tourism numbers from Germany. Lastly, discussions were entered into with Lufthansa regarding direct flights between Munich and Cape Town, following the announcement of the cancellation of these flights by SAA. Lufthansa initiated direct flights from October 2012 and a better understanding of their business case was obtained. |
|
VISIT TO THE UNITED STATES, 15 until 19 April 2012 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of Economic Development and Tourism |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The main purpose of the visit was to promote trade and investment between the US and the province [including with Florida], investigate alternatives for Free Trade Zones and explore opportunities for Renewable Energy innovation. Discussions were entered with several industry bodies including the US Chamber of Commerce, Enterprise Florida, etc. as well as with senior officials within the US Government, e.g. with the Department of Energy regarding opportunities re renewable energy, etc. The potential for investment in the Business Process Outsourcing in the Western Cape were highlighted as an opportunity. Direct air access was highlighted as an inhibitor for increase business linkages with the province. |
|
ATTENDANCE OF 6TH REGIONAL LEADERS’ SUMMIT [BRAZIL], 10 until 14 April 2012 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The purpose of the visit was to attend the 9th Regional Leaders’ Summit. The bulk of the Western Cape’s international engagements take place within the ambit of the Regional Leaders’ Forum. The 9th forum took place under the theme “Energy Transition: Towards a Low-carbon Economy”. In addition, exchanges took place with the Government in Rio de Janeiro regarding their pacification programme [safety and security initiative in the favelas] as well as opportunities for closer collaboration as far as tourism are concerned. Discussions were also entered into with the organisers of the Rio Boat Show, bearing in mind that the boat building sector was growing in the province. Lastly discussions were entered into with the Royal Yacht club in Rio de Janeiro, one of the co-organisers of the Cape to Rio yacht race. |
|
VISIT TO NAMIBIA, 24 and 25 January 2012 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of the Premier |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The WCG was exploring the possibility of implementing a “high street model”, which limits the selling of liquor to specific areas. The visit to Namibia enabled the WCG to see the system implemented in an area similar to what would be experienced in areas in the Western Cape [urban area]. The Western Cape benefitted from engaging with various stakeholders involved in the implementation of liquor legislation in Namibia, and the lessons learned influenced the Western Cape in its approach as far as the high street model was concerned. |
|
VISIT TO SINGAPORE, 16 until 21 October 2011 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of Economic Development and Tourism |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The visit assisted with promotion of the Western Cape as a preferred tourist destination through exhibiting at the ITB Asia, engaging with top Asian tour operators and other global players as well as attending a Spotlight Singapore high-level networking function. As a result of the Spotlight Singapore event, DEDAT’s Cape Catalyst unit liaised with Infocomm Development Authority of Singapore [IDA] and a 2-day workshop were held in the Western Cape during December 2012. The WCG further engaged with key stakeholders in the Singaporean Oil and Gas sector [one of the leaders globally] and the lessons learned were implemented in the Western Cape’s approach in promoting the sector in the province. Lastly the visit also resulted in the WC [DEDAT and Wesgro] participating in the Africa Singapore Business Forum that took place in August 2012, including the hosting of a Cape Fair with the Ministry of Trade and Industry [MTI] and the South African High Commission in Singapore. |
|
VISIT TO ANGOLA, 25 until 28 September 2011 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Wesgro, in collaboration with Trade and Investment KwaZulu/Natal [TIKZN] and DTI |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The WCG obtained a clearer understanding of business opportunities in Angola, including blockages that prevented stronger trade and investment relations. Opportunities for closer collaboration were also explored as far as the SBIDZ was concerned regarding the servicing of oil rigs, Construction, Agri-processing, tourism and education. Discussions were also entered into regarding ANIP and Wesgro forging a closer working relationship to promote business-to-business linkages. |
|
VISIT TO SAUDI ARABIA AND THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES, 09 until 15 December 2010 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Wesgro, in collaboration with Trade and Investment KwaZulu/Natal [TIKZN] and DTI |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The visit explored closer business linkages with Saudi Arabia [and regional trade and investment promotion agencies in Saudi] in the Construction, Renewable Energy, Agriculture, Oil and Gas, IT, Health care and infrastructure, and back-office support. The WCG obtained a clearer understanding of business opportunities in Saudi Arabia as well as areas of interest Saudi companies were interested in investing in, e.g. an invitation was extended to Saudi companies to attend the Tourism Indaba, the Jeddah Chamber of Commerce expressed a desire to bring a delegation of leading captains of Industry to South Africa and the province, etc. In addition, collaboration between the Shoura Council and the WCPP was encouraged as far as legislative processes were concerned. Similarly, a clearer overview was obtained of Abu Dhabi 2030 Vision and the opportunities for and synergies with the WC. An invitation was extended to ADDED to visit the WC to explore opportunities for closer business linkages. Furthermore, the Western Cape delegation was granted access to the database of the Dubai Chamber of Commerce for potential matchmaking. Similarly, discussions were entered into regarding the export of Agricultural products, Halaal certification and Renewable Energy with the Minister of Foreign Trade. Discussions were also entered into with Masdar City regarding the possibility for the implementation of technology in energy saving. Lastly, discussions were entered into with Etihad airlines regarding cargo load from Cape Town. |
|
VISIT TO THE UNITED KINGDOM, 09 until 12 November 2009 |
TRIP DETAILS |
|
Organiser [Department] |
Department of Economic Development and Tourism |
Delegation |
|
Purpose |
|
Destination |
|
MEETING DETAILS |
|
Organisation & official met |
|
Outcomes pursued & benefits |
The delegation attended the WTM, the premier gathering of tourism operators. The event served as a platform to market and promote the offering of the province to a global audience and engage with stakeholders relevant to the sector e.g. airlines, tourism agencies, etc. Engagements were also set up with stakeholders in the tourism, hospitality and financial services sectors to explore opportunities for the Western Cape. Practical advance and suggestions were received regarding the way forward for heritage rail in the Western Cape and the country, including but not limited to the structures, budgets, maintenance and restoration of the locomotives, economic impact of the railways on the local economy, marketing strategies, funding models, insight into the establishment and management of heritage railway museums, community involvement, etc. A strong focus was placed on the Outeniqua Choo Tjoe and possible collaboration in this regard. |
[1] The information requested covers nearly a decade. Every effort has been taken to collate this information as accurately as possible in the time provided.
[2] Sunday, 05 November 2017 was utilised as a working day.
[3] Minister Winde didn’t attend the meeting as it clashed with the NMF and Thebe Group breakfast.
[4] Minister Winde didn’t attend the meeting as it clashed with the NMF and Thebe Group breakfast.
[5] Radio Conference that can reach 100 million listeners from 10 countries.
[6] Sunday, 21 May 2022 was utilised as a working day.
[7] Minister Winde had a parallel meeting with Stanford university and didn’t attend the meeting.
[8] Sunday, 15 November 2015 was also utilised for a meeting with Hisense, who’s based in Atlantis.
[9] Meeting attended by Minister Meyer only as it clashed with meeting with Shanghai Free Trade Zone
[10] Sunday, 26 April 2015 was utilised as a working day.
[11] Saturday, 28 March 2015 was utilised as a working day.
[12] Saturday, 06 October 2012 was also utilised for work-related purposes.
[13] Minister Winde didn’t attend the meeting as he had a parallel programme in Rio, including meetings with State Secretary for Tourism, Rio Yacht club, Rio Boat Show, etc.
[14] See foot note 13 above.
[15] Sunday, 25 September 2011 was utilised as a working day.
[16] The meeting was only for the representative of Truworths and not the official delegation.
[17] The meeting happened concurrently with the meeting with the International Petroleum Investment Corporation and as such Minister Winde was not in attendance.
[18] The meeting was managed by Minister van Rensburg as the main topic of discussion was food security and the banning of SA red meat into market.
[19][19] Included only the business delegation
[20] Business delegation only.