Health
(a) What are the details of (i) medical and (ii) other lawsuits her Department has been involved since 2009 and (b) for each (i) what was the outcome, (ii) total associated cost per case and (iii) the overall amount budgeted against expenditure?
Attached please find a detailed analysis of each case since 2009 – including settlements and cases which were denied compensation. The response below is a summary in of only the cases which reached settlements.
2009/2010
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
TYGERBERG |
SETTLEMENT |
R 400 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
|
GEORGE |
SETTLEMENT |
R 100 000.00 |
R 35 000.00 |
R 65 000.00 |
|
GSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 351 000.00 |
R 240 000.00 |
R 111 000.00 |
|
GSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 6 002 149.00 |
R 350 000.00 |
R 5 652 149.00 |
|
VICTORIA HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 482 685.49 |
R 270 000.00 |
R 212 685.49 |
|
KRAAIFONTEIN CHC |
SETTLEMENT |
R 220 000.00 |
R 160 000.00 |
R 60 000.00 |
|
GSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 100 000.00 |
R 20 000.00 |
R 80 000.00 |
|
STELLENBOSCH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 120 000.00 |
R 120 000.00 |
R 0.00 |
|
GSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 103 000.00 |
R 70 000.00 |
R 33 000.00 |
|
BEAUFORT WEST |
SETTLEMENT |
R 300 000.00 |
R 170 000.00 |
R 130 000.00 |
|
TOTAL |
|
R 8 178 834.49 |
R 1 635 000.00 |
R 6 543 834.49 |
2010/2011
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
MITCHELL'S PLAIN CHC |
SETTLEMENT |
R 8 205 000.00 |
R 856 627.50 |
R 7 348 372.50 |
|
ORAL HEALTH CENTRE |
SETTLEMENT |
R 135 850.88 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 35 850.88 |
|
TYGERBERG |
SETTLEMENT |
R 269 449.54 |
R 143 000.00 |
R 126 449.54 |
|
GSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 160 000.00 |
R 50 000.00 |
R 110 000.00 |
|
KHAYELITSHA MOU |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 507 000.00 |
R 490 000.00 |
R 1 458 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG |
SETTLEMENT |
R 250 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 50 000.00 |
|
BISHOP LAVIS CHC |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 000 000.00 |
R 550 000.00 |
R 450 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG |
SETTLEMENT |
R 300 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
|
GF JOOSTE HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 109 500.00 |
R 75 000.00 |
R 34 500.00 |
|
WORCESTER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 10 764 800.00 |
R 1 200 000.00 |
R 9 564 800.00 |
|
TYGERBERG |
SETTLEMENT |
R 300 000.00 |
R 230 000.00 |
R 70 000.00 |
|
GSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 9 971 350.00 |
R 4 616 530.00 |
R 5 354 820.00 |
|
TOTAL |
|
R 32 972 950.42 |
R 8 711 157.50 |
R 24 702 792.92 |
2011/2012
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
GSH |
|
R 100 000.00 |
R 20 000.00 |
R 80 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG |
|
R 100 000.00 |
R 25 000.00 |
R 75 000.00 |
|
PAARL |
|
R 210 000.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 110 000.00 |
|
CLANWILLIAM |
|
R 5 041 710.00 |
R 4 100 000.00 |
R 941 710.00 |
|
HELDERBERG |
|
R 264 000.00 |
R 110 000.00 |
R 154 000.00 |
|
SWARTLAND |
|
R 100 000.00 |
R 30 000.00 |
R 70 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG |
|
R 3 346 010.00 |
R 4 700 000.00 |
|
|
MACASSAR MOU |
|
R 477 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 277 000.00 |
|
GEORGE |
|
R 250 000.00 |
R 105 000.00 |
R 145 000.00 |
|
HELDERBERG |
|
R 350 000.00 |
R 120 000.00 |
R 23 000.00 |
|
GSH |
|
R 598 500.00 |
R 300 000.00 |
R 298 500.00 |
|
MITCHELLS PLAIN CHC |
|
R 8 205 000.00 |
R 892 800.00 |
R 7 312 200.00 |
|
TYGERBERG |
|
R 11 832 000.00 |
R 5 100 000.00 |
R 6 732 000.00 |
|
GSH |
|
R 200 500.00 |
R 95 000.00 |
R 105 500.00 |
|
TOTAL |
|
R 31 074 720.00 |
R 15 897 800.00 |
R 16 323 910.00 |
2012/2013
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
MOSSEL BAY HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 310 000.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 210 000.00 |
|
WESFLEUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 315 000.00 |
R 220 000.00 |
R 95 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 539 000.00 |
R 135 000.00 |
R 404 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 531 000.00 |
R 65 000.00 |
R 466 000.00 |
|
MOWBRAY MATERNITY HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 233 645.00 |
R 50 000.00 |
R 183 645.00 |
|
GROOTE SCHUUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 852 000.00 |
R 95 000.00 |
R 757 000.00 |
|
HELDERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 045 127.00 |
R 530 000.00 |
R 515 127.00 |
|
WORCESTER CHC/ WORCESTER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 850 000.00 |
R 210 000.00 |
R 640 000.00 |
|
VICTORIA HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 450 000.00 |
R 90 000.00 |
R 360 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOPSITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 92 040.00 |
R 25 000.00 |
R 67 040.00 |
|
PAARL HOPSITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 7 101 000.00 |
R 4 000 000.00 |
R 3 101 000.00 |
|
KNYSNA HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 750 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 550 000.00 |
|
GROOTE SCHUUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 509 000.00 |
R 177 147.05 |
R 331 852.95 |
|
TOTAL |
R 16 577 812.00 |
R 6 197 147.05 |
R 10 380 664.95 |
2013/2014
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
MICHAEL MAPONGWANA MOU |
SETTLEMENT |
R 3 000 000.00 |
R 300 000.00 |
R 2 700 000.00 |
|
WESTERN CAPE REHABILITATION CENTRE |
SETTLEMENT |
R 950 000.00 |
R 72 000.00 |
R 878 000.00 |
|
BASHIP LAVIS MOU/ KARL BREMER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
|
R 2 150 000.00 |
|
|
BASHIP LAVIS MOU/ KARL BREMER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 21 219 500.00 |
R 3 200 000.00 |
R 15 869 500.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 495 000.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 395 000.00 |
|
CONRADIE CARE CENTRE |
SETTLEMENT |
R 600 000.00 |
R 30 000.00 |
R 570 000.00 |
|
OUDTSHOORN HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 90 000.00 |
R 40 000.00 |
R 50 000.00 |
|
EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES |
SETTLEMENT |
|
R 920 000.00 |
|
|
OUDTSHOORN HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 16 142 779.00 |
R 6 830 000.00 |
R 8 392 779.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 659 500.77 |
R 2 200 000.00 |
|
|
KARL BREMER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 050 100.00 |
R 85 000.00 |
R 961 500.00 |
|
KHAYELITSHA COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTRE |
SETTLEMENT |
R 125 000.00 |
R 70 000.00 |
R 55 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 850 000.00 |
R 280 000.00 |
R 570 000.00 |
|
MICHAEL MAPONGWANA MOU |
SETTLEMENT |
R 100 000.00 |
R 70 000.00 |
R 30 000.00 |
|
MICHAEL MAPONGWANA MOU |
SETTLEMENT |
R 16 537 000.00 |
R 250 000.00 |
R 16 287 000.00 |
|
ALBOW GARDENS CHC / NSH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 8 284 500.00 |
R 1 300 000.00 |
R 6 984 500.00 |
|
RED CROSS HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 473 415.00 |
R 90 000.00 |
R 383 415.00 |
|
DELFT CHC / TBH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 32 156 874.75 |
R 1 500 000.00 |
|
|
MOWBRAY MATERNITY HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 20 851 515.63 |
R 1 500 000.00 |
|
|
CITRUSDAL HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 32 156 874.75 |
R 1 500 000.00 |
|
|
GROOTE SCHUUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 000 000.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 900 000.00 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL |
|
R 156 742 059.90 |
R 22 587 000.00 |
R 54 126 694.00 |
2014/2015
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
WORCESTER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 10 315 200.00 |
R 4 717 615.00 |
|
|
KARL BREMER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 450 000.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 250 000.00 |
|
GROOTE SCHUUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 530 000.00 |
R 135 000.00 |
R 395 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 513 339.89 |
R 140 000.00 |
R 373 339.89 |
|
GROOTE SCHUUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 120 000.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 20 000.00 |
|
HANNA COETZEE CLINIC/ VREDENBURG |
SETTLEMENT |
R 2 540 000.00 |
R 1 227 660.00 |
R 1 312 340.00 |
|
RETREAT MOU |
SETTLEMENT |
R 400 400.00 |
R 220 000.00 |
R 180 400.00 |
|
GROOTE SCHUUR HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 6 583 840.00 |
R 540 000.00 |
R 6 043 840.00 |
|
CLANWILLIAM HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 532 100.00 |
R 100 000.00 |
R 432 100.00 |
|
MOWBRAY HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 8 000 000.00 |
R 561 600.00 |
R 7 438 400.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 900 000.00 |
R 150 000.00 |
R 750 000.00 |
|
DELFT CHC/ TBH |
SETTLEMENT |
R 32 156 874.75 |
R 7 829 205.30 |
R 24 327 669.45 |
|
WORCESTER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 207 009.00 |
R 150 000.00 |
R 57 009.00 |
|
MOWBRAY HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 468 400.00 |
R 275 000.00 |
R 193 400.00 |
|
IDAS VALLEY CLINIC |
SETTLEMENT |
R 410 000.00 |
R 45 000.00 |
R 365 000.00 |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 642 844.00 |
R 500 000.00 |
R 1 142 844.00 |
|
FALSE BAY HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 317 800.00 |
R 200 000.00 |
R 117 800.00 |
|
PAARL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 450 000.00 |
R 220 000.00 |
R 230 000.00 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL |
|
R 66 537 807.64 |
R 17 311 080.30 |
R 43 629 142.34 |
2015/2016 (TO DATE)
|
HOSPITAL |
OUTCOME |
AMOUNT ACTUALLY CLAIMED |
SETTLEMENT AMOUNT |
SAVED |
|
TYGERBERG HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 115 000.00 |
R 115 000.00 |
R 0.00 |
|
MITCHELL'S PLAIN CHC |
SETTLEMENT |
R 420 000.00 |
R 250 000.00 |
R 170 000.00 |
|
EERSTE RIVER HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 852 475.30 |
R 920 000.00 |
R 932 475.30 |
|
PORTERVILLE CLINIC / LAPA MUNNIK HOSPITAL |
SETTLEMENT |
R 1 170 000.00 |
R 1 170 000.00 |
R 0.00 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL |
|
R 3 557 475.30 |
R 2 455 000.00 |
R 1 102 475.30 |
