Education
In respect of the Department’s tender BWCED 3124/23: Supply and Deliver of Stationery to the Head Office, Education District Offices and Approximately 250 Non-Section 21 Schools of the Western Cape Education Department for a Period of Three Years:
- Whether he can make available the (a) complete bid documents for the tender, (b) details of all the companies that submitted bids, (c) bid evaluation recommendations, (d) scoring per company and (e) final report of the bid committee;
- (a) what is the detailed explanation of the verification process used to assess the compliance of bidders and (b) what checks were in place to ensure that all the companies met the necessary requirements before being awarded the tender;
- whether all the companies that submitted bids were (a) VAT-registered or (b) CSD-compliant at the time of the bid closure on 16 February 2024; if not, what are the details of the companies that were not compliant; if so, what are the relevant details;
- what are the details of the company or companies that were awarded the tender;
- whether the company or companies that were awarded the tender were VAT-registered and/or CSD-compliant at the time of the bid closure on 16 February 2024; if not, how was the company’s bid considered compliant under these conditions; if so, what are the relevant details;
- whether the alleged reports that a certain company, whose name has been furnished to his Department for the purpose of his reply, only registered for VAT in August 2024 have been bought to his attention; if so, (a) how were its bid documents, which included financial statements reflecting a turnover of nearly R18 million, evaluated and deemed acceptable and (b) what are the details of the evaluation process?
15. My department has informed me of the following:
(1) (a) Please see attached Annexures A and B.
(b) The Department received 19 bid offers at bid closure on 16 February 2024:
No | Name of Bidder |
1 | BIDTIQ (PTY) LTD |
2 | Gicha Coffee Shop (Pty) Ltd |
3 | Swiftcare Holdings (Pty) Ltd |
4 | Quadrant Holdings CC |
5 | Black Soft |
6 | Lbc Multiserv |
7 | Agisanang Business Services |
8 | Stat Books CC |
9 | Lutak Consulting |
10 | Sibanye Office Solutions |
11 | Razistep |
12 | SAAVU Solutions |
13 | Gemini Stationery Manufacturers |
14 | Park Avenue Stationers |
15 | Ngaphaya Y2k10 Trading |
16 | Bidvest Waltons |
17 | Mjuleni Services |
18 | Xenocorp 279 |
19 | Caprichem SACCS |
Seven were non-compliant.
No | Name of Bidder |
1 | Swiftcare Holdings (Pty) Ltd |
2 | Black Soft |
3 | Agisanang Business Services |
4 | Lutak Consulting |
5 | Razistep |
6 | Bidvest Waltons |
7 | Mjuleni Services |
(c) to (e) Yes, though a Promotion of Access to Information Act (PAIA) application.
- All bids were evaluated against the advertised bidding criteria and requirements applicable to the registration on the National Treasury Central Supplier Database (CSD) and tax compliance status.
(3) The requirements are that the recommended service provider(s) must be tax compliant at the time of award and registered on the National Treasury CSD. Both the recommended bidders were reflected as tax compliant on the National Treasury CSD at the time of award.
(4) The bid was awarded to the companies indicated in the table below:
Service No. | Description | Bidders’ Names |
1. | Supply and deliver stationery to schools within the combined Metro Education Districts (Central, East, North & South) including the Education District Offices as well as Head Office. | |
2. | Supply and deliver stationery to schools within the Cape Winelands Education District including the Education District Office. | |
3. | Supply and deliver stationery to schools within the Overberg Education District including the Education District Office. | LBC Multiserv |
4. | Supply and deliver stationery to schools within the West Coast Education District including the Education District Office. | LBC Multiserv |
5. | Supply and deliver stationery to schools within the Eden & Central Karoo Education District including the Education District Office. | LBC Multiserv |
(5) The bid requirements were that the recommended service provider(s) must be tax compliant at the time of award and registered on the National Treasury CSD. Both the recommended bidders were reflected as tax compliant on the National Treasury CSD at the time of award.
(6) All bids were evaluated against the advertised bidding criteria. The bid requirements were that the recommended service provider(s) must be tax compliant at the time of award and registered on the National Treasury CSD.